Cookbooks: Peach Cobbler

Tuesday, August 28, 2012

-Yes, I keep the skins on the peaches. They give the cobbler a beautiful rhodocrosite color.-

So this may sound odd, but I'm not a big cookbook person. Most of my food friends have walls - literally, walls - stuffed full of cookbooks and their floors are dotted with towers of information on such topics as gluten-free baking and how to cure a tagine. Rooms are bordered by imposing culinary skylines pushed against the walls in order to make a path to the kitchen.

To me it's like a head packed to the brim with too many thoughts. No way to give them all enough attention or sort them all properly. And like thoughts, some are lost never to be seen again until one day you seem to trip over it out of the blue (probably when moving). Others are gems that you treasure and invest your time into while others are inane and you wonder how on earth this awkward tome came to be.

I ask these friends if they use all of these cookbooks. These literally hundreds - and for one, thousands - of tomes. Do you use them all? Really?

The answer is usually yes. Often followed by the modifier, "Eventually..."

Dot. Dot. Dot.

-I'm not sure I always believe them.-

They use them as reference in order to compare and contrast. They use them as textbooks to learn from. Art books to be inspired by and to draw from. A way to enhance one's own photography and point of view. Sometimes, because you want to find just the right waffle recipe and you won't know which one it is until you read through fifteen others.

These are all good enough reasons. However, maybe at times it can be just too much information. At the very least it's repetitious.

Now I'm not much of a hoarder. I purge. Often. Except my own words when I write. Those I hold on to with a grip so tight you would think I were holding onto life itself. (But aren't words life? I think so.) But I purge things. Stuff.

Ugh... I hate STUFF.

I don't like having so much crap in my house. I want it out and gone.

I'm particular on which cookbooks I adopt and bring into my home. I only have a little bit of space that's pretty much filled up, so soon I'll need to invest in a larger bookshelf or begin constructing my own little cities against the wall, too. I pick books that are good for reference. Rarely do I pick one up simply because it's pretty. Some of my favorite books have no pictures. After all, Irma Rombauer and Diana Kennedy certainly didn't need them.

I choose books for their usefulness. I want unique. I want helpful. Educational is key. Practicality is prized.

I almost always buy the cookbooks my friends write, because I know and trust their thoughts and opinions. I know that I will use their books. (I also feel it is good book karma.)

I want all of my books filled with stains from chicken blood or raspberries or whatnot. I want pages crusted with flour and stuck together from a stray gloop of honey. I want torn covers and annotations. I want to see my handwriting scribbled across the page with wine suggestions, alternatives, adaptations, and the occasional X through the page or a giant "YES!" scrawled across the top. Nothing is more endearing to me than a cookbook as shaggy and dog-eared as a border collie.

-It's a small three shelf bookshelf. Maybe 40 cookbooks I would say?-

I admit, one or two cookbooks will never see a kitchen. They're educational. The lessons and history wedged into their pages are far more important than the meals they detail.

So yes, I'm a huge cookbook person. Just a rather picky one.

Today I felt like making peach cobbler. I know the method and the means, but I wanted some other opnions. I consulted Deborah Madison, flipped through Lindsey Shere, talked to Dorie Greenspan, chatted to my bud David Lebovitz, and had a socratic discussion with Regan Daley and Cindy Mushet.

Here's what we came up with. It might be the best. It might not. It's subjective, really. I think we all know that. It's a laid back peach cobbler recipe spiked with a lot of vanilla. Personally, I think vanilla makes everything better. It is, obviously, one of my favorite flavors.

Now, I'll close blogger and save this post. I'm going to my kitchen to eat cobbler with a mug of over-steeped black tea and sit down with my new cookbook and see what Molly Stevens has to teach me about roasting.

Will report back later.

Garrett out.

Vanilla Garlic's Peach Cobbler
3-4 large peaches, pitted and sliced
1 cup vanilla sugar (or plain 'ol sugar)
1 tablespoon vanilla extract
1 tablespoon rum
2 teaspoons lemon juice
1 tablespoon corn starch

Cobbler Dough 
3 tablespoons sugar
1 cup flour
1 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
1/4 teaspoon salt
1/4 teaspoon cinnamon
4 tablespoons butter, diced
1/3 cup milk
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
1 egg, lightly beaten

1. Preheat oven to 350F. To make the filling combine all the filling ingredients in a bowl and allow to macerate for about 15 minutes. Then pour into a buttered 9x9 baking dish.

2. For the dough, whisk together the sugar, flour, baking powder, salt, and cinnamon. Add the butter in and cut it together with a pastry blender or your fingers until it looks like coarse crumbs. Combine in a bowl the milk, egg, and extract and add the mixture to the dry ingredients and mix it once or twice until it just comes together. Drop spoonfuls of the dough over the peaches - be lazy about this. It makes the drops work better.

3. Bake at for 50-55 minutes or until the top is golden brown. Serve and enjoy.


  1. I'm bookmarking this for next summer, when my tree is once again groaning with peaches and I have made all of the jam, salsa and pie I can stomach.

    1. There's a peach BBQ sauce on this site you may love, too. ;)

    2. OMG! Can I second that?! I made that BBQ Sauce and it's AHHH-MAZING!

  2. I am with you on the cookbooks. I have two James Beard, one Jacques Pepin, the old school Better Homes red and white checkered one, and a few appetizer ones. I am super picky about cookbooks. I hate clutter.

  3. I'm one of those people who has an entire wall of cookbooks, half of which I use regularly and half that I've only looked for the pretty pictures. So it's true, most of them aren't needed, but I still love that they are there on the shelves as reliable friends to be consulted IF I should need them in the future.

    Of course, generations of home cooks have also gone through life with just a very splattered copy of the Joy of Cooking or another favorite cookbook. And have cooked a lot of great meals using that one cookbook. I guess we just live in an age in which we need to know there are limitless recipes available to us!

    1. True, so why have so many books when the internet is so vast? Because the internet is a fickle liar with many untested recipes.

    2. You are so right. I have lost count of the number of finished dishes I have pitched in the garbage from an internet recipe. Too many "food" bloggers out there. I am pretty selective about those now also.

  4. I think you should end every post with "Garrett out." :-)

    1. Hmm, def. something to consider.
      -Garrett Out

  5. Less peaches, more wedding pictures :)

    1. They aren't done yet. I'm waiting for them. =)

    2. Thirded with ENTHUSIASM. So much support and delight for you. -Phx Az

    3. Okay, I take back the part about less peaches. I made this last night and it was delicious. I swapped out brandy for the rum, since I'm not a big rum drinker and didn't have any on hand, and I thought they played nicely together. I also topped it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, and it melted so nicely with the peach juice. A perfect celebration of summer, I thought.
      Now, back to sitting on my hands and waiting for wedding pictures.

  6. I agree with Michelle...more wedding pictures please!!! Congratulations on your marriage! And thanks for the great peach cobbler to go to the liquor store for more rum!

  7. I can't wait for our cookbooks to be on each others' bookshelves. :) I promise to stain yours with melted cheese ASAP.

  8. I opened my computer wanting to find a peach cobbler recipe, happened to come here first and here it is! It's like you read my mind. I just took mine out of the oven. My apartment smells heavenly.

  9. Ha - that cracks me up reading it and then seeing you have FORTY cookbooks which to me is way more than I could ever imagine having. I have 8 or 9, with the two best being my Good Housekeeping Cookbook that my mom gave me at 17 (with my scrawled 'recipe' for how to cook rice and boil an egg on the inside) and The Silver Spoon, a behemoth but one that is so amazing for those miraculous 5-ingredient recipes that taste like heaven. Other than that, I had my own collected recipes turned into binders and that's primarily where I refer. I can't imagine giving up major amounts of space in my kitchen to books that aren't touched - it's kind of like my closet!

  10. Wedding pictures! Also wanting your new cookbook to add to my ever growing collection! :)

  11. I'm with you on the cookbooks! I'm a book whore but I only have about 20 cookbooks but I use every single one of them as references, cross reference, their actual recipes, etc. I am constantly refering to my cookbooks. I love them with a passion!

  12. I have a kind a same opinion as you about all recipes and cookbooks. I can cook my self but Im not going to spend my life in kitchen. Just couple meals and thats all.

  13. I am an online recipe addict. I have folders full of recipes and ideas on my computer. My biggest addiction now is Pinterest and the recipes you find there!

  14. I don't like peaches at all but this post gives me a delicious recipe so I must going to try this dish very soon, Tiffinzs

    1. Ayesha, you can try it with cherries instead if peaches aren't really your thing.

  15. Making it now with 45 minutes left on the timer. Ran out of butter, so I used half butter half cream cheese. What kind of a baker (or bakest) runs out of butter!?


Hey, you're leaving a comment! That's pretty darn cool, so thanks. If you have any questions or have found an error on the site or with a recipe, please e-mail me and I will reply as soon as possible.

Vanilla Garlic All rights reserved © Blog Milk Powered by Blogger